Why you make worse food choices at the end of the day, and how to fix it

Decision fatigue builds through the day and makes dinner the hardest choice of all. Simple ways to make fewer decisions and eat better in the evening.

Why you make worse food choices at the end of the day, and how to fix it
Why you make worse food choices at the end of the day, and how to fix it

From the moment your alarm goes off, you're making decisions. Most are so small you don't notice them: whether to get up now or in five minutes, what to wear, which email to answer first, whether to say yes to another meeting. Each one takes a little out of you, and the longer the day goes on, the more your decision-making power wears down.

By dinnertime, plenty of us have very little left. You open the fridge, nothing appeals, you can't face working out what to cook, and whatever is quickest wins. That's decision fatigue, and it can seriously affect your health, because the decisions that suffer are often about food and they come at the end of the day, when you're most tired. Researchers still debate exactly how it works, but most people recognise the feeling.

Why dinner is the hardest decision of the day

When you're worn out, you want something fast and filling. That often means food high in refined carbohydrates, the quickly digested kind found in white bread, pasta, crisps and a lot of takeaways, eaten without much protein or veg to slow it down. There's nothing wrong with any of these now and then. The trouble is what they do to your glucose, the sugar in your blood that your body runs on. Glucose rises after you eat and falls again, and a meal like that can send it up quickly and back down just as fast, which can leave you hungry and rummaging in the cupboard again by nine o'clock.

You regret it later, promise yourself you'll do better tomorrow, and the next evening you're just as tired. Willpower at 7pm is a poor plan. A better one is to make fewer decisions in the first place.

Take the decisions out before you get there

Planning ahead is the simplest fix. If you sit down at the weekend and decide what you'll have for dinner each night of the coming week, there's no decision to make when you get home. You can get on with cooking and enjoy eating it. It doesn't need to be elaborate: a list on the fridge and the right food in the house does most of the work.

The same idea works beyond the kitchen. Back when Barack Obama was president, you'd only ever see him in a blue or grey suit. He explained in an interview that he had so many other decisions to make that he wanted to pare down the mundane ones, and he mentioned what he ate as well as what he wore. Mark Zuckerberg has said much the same about his signature grey T-shirt.

You don't have to go as far as wearing a different version of the same thing every day, but a capsule wardrobe, a small set of clothes that all go together, takes one more decision off your morning.

If you plan ahead, there's no decision to make at mealtimes. You can simply focus on preparing your food and enjoying it.

Give your brain fewer things to juggle

We often fill spare moments with things that create yet more decisions: looking at the phone, browsing the internet, scrolling social media. Every post, message and notification is another small choice about whether to read, reply or keep going. Cutting back on these distractions, even just in the evening, leaves more in the tank for the decisions that matter.

It's worth looking at how busy you are, too. For plenty of people a week looks something like this: dinner with a parent on Monday, drinks with a friend on Tuesday, a photography course on Wednesday, entertaining clients on Thursday, work training on Friday, choir practice on Saturday, and Sunday spent on anything but rest. With modern life that full, it's little wonder our brains get overloaded and struggle to make decisions. Trimming the diary where you can helps. That might mean one or two social plans a week, fewer after-school activities for the children, or spreading work tasks across the week instead of piling them up. With a bit of structure around your schedule, you'll probably find your capacity to make decisions goes up.

Clutter is draining for the same reason: it keeps presenting you with choices. If you can see the pile of letters on the side, you'll keep asking yourself whether to pay the water bill now or later, or whether to set up a direct debit. Clutter is better out of sight, somewhere you can deal with it when you have the headspace. Shoving everything in a cupboard doesn't work, though, because you'll forget it's there. A dedicated spot for everything that needs dealing with works better, with the task written on your to-do list as each thing goes in.

What to try this week

A good week starts with four or five evening meals written down and shopped for in one go, built around protein and plenty of vegetables so they keep you full through the evening. A couple of breakfasts and lunches you're happy to eat on repeat stop being decisions too. A few fallbacks in the freezer or cupboard, such as frozen vegetables, tinned fish or eggs, cover the nights when the plan falls apart. Leaving your phone in another room for the first hour after dinner helps, and so does finding one commitment in your diary to drop or move.

None of this needs much willpower, which is rather the point. By dinnertime most of us have already answered more questions than we could count. The trick is making sure what to eat was settled days ago.

Photo by Samsung UK

How Nico helps

Wear a sensor, log your breakfast, and your coach will tell you by lunchtime whether it worked.

Start your resetHow it works

This article is general information, not medical advice. If you're worried about your blood sugar, talk to your GP.

Useful things, now and then.

A short email from the Nico team. No streaks, no guilt.

See it. Understand it.
Change it.

Start your reset300 places this month