Why South Asian men get type 2 diabetes 20 years earlier: Dr David Unwin explains

Why South Asian men get type 2 diabetes 20 years earlier: Dr David Unwin explains
Why South Asian men get type 2 diabetes 20 years earlier: Dr David Unwin explains

Indian, Pakistani, Bangladeshi and Sri Lankan men can get into trouble with insulin resistance decades before their white friends, often with a normal BMI. In the first episode of The Metabolic Movement, the GP behind 159 drug-free type 2 diabetes remissions explains why, and what South Asian families can do about it.

For the first 25 years of his career as a GP, Dr David Unwin didn't see a single case of type 2 diabetes remission without medication. He has now seen 159. He told a room of people from industry, government and education at a metabolic health summit in Switzerland that if you aren't seeing drug-free remission, you need to ask why.

We sat down with him there, just after World Diabetes Day, to ask a question that matters to millions of British Asian families. Our co-founder Liton's family are from Bangladesh, and type 2 diabetes in South Asians is far more common than in the white population. England's own men's health strategy says deaths from diabetes and heart attacks are typically highest among South Asian men. So we asked David why.

Insulin resistance in Asian men starts 20 years earlier

David's answer was blunt. In his experience, Asian men probably get into difficulty with insulin resistance about 20 years earlier than white men do. Part of it is genetic. Part of it, he says, is that South Asian people tend to carry less muscle, and muscle is a good place for glucose from a meal to go.

He also sees it as an adaptation that has turned against people. He describes a body built to survive famine as one that's very good at storing fat when food is plentiful. That's an advantage when the harvest might fail next year. It becomes a liability when chapati, rice, naan, biscuits and sugary chai are available all day, every day.

Normal BMI, hidden belly fat

The warning sign is easy to miss. David says he's particularly careful with Asian men who start getting a bit of middle-age spread in their twenties. Their BMI is often normal, so nobody worries. In his view, that small belly is visceral fat, the fat around your organs, and the start of insulin resistance. Some people call this "thin outside, fat inside". It's why the NHS uses lower BMI thresholds for people of South Asian heritage.

His advice is to get a blood test. An HbA1c test shows whether you're heading towards pre-diabetes or type 2 diabetes, and David sees a pre-diabetes result as good news: you've found out early enough to do something about it.

Rice, ghee and what your great-grandparents ate

The Western diet hits hardest in the communities that adopted it most recently. David has seen this in Malaysia, where ice cream and McDonald's have become status symbols for wealthier families, and he has seen it among Indigenous communities around the world.

Liton told him about visiting his grandmother in Bangladesh in the 1980s. She fed him rice he spat out, because it wasn't the fluffy white rice he knew from home. It was shorter and browner. White rice was rich people's rice, and taking the husks off by hand took her ages.

David's suggestion is that whoever you are, it's worth finding out how your great-grandparents ate, because that's the diet your body is adapted to. For many desi families that meant brown rice, lots of green vegetables, fish and ghee, very little sugar and no seed oils. In his view, diabetes would have been rare in those villages, and the arrival of white rice and sugar is why it isn't now.

He pointed to the work of Weston Price, a dentist who travelled the world in the 1930s. Price compared communities where white flour, white sugar and jam had just arrived with their relatives who still ate traditionally, including Swiss valleys with and without a new railway. David says that within about ten years teeth decayed, children's jaws became narrower, and diseases such as tuberculosis took hold. He argues that a diet that keeps insulin in check supports a stronger immune system.

David also believes that 19th-century British surgeons working in India reported how rare cancer was there and weren't believed back home. In his view, at least half to two-thirds of cancer is linked to the Western diet.

The one thing every young South Asian man should know

We asked what he'd want every young British Asian man to hear. His answer was that diet matters far more to your future than most of us were brought up to think. We grow up seeing medicine as drugs and surgery, and food as a minor detail. His own practice taught him the opposite: a low carb approach has put patient after patient into type 2 diabetes remission.

Much better to know your blood sugar now than after a heart attack, a stroke or an amputation. At 68, he says, he can race his grandchildren, and he thinks six months of better eating can make that kind of difference to anyone.

If your belt has started creeping out in your twenties or thirties and your BMI still says you're fine, which of those two numbers are you going to believe?

Dr David Unwin was instrumental in setting up the Preventive Health Collaboration, a UK charity. If this episode was useful to you, please support their work.

Subscribe to our podcast here: The Metabolic Movement

How Nico helps

Wear a sensor, log your breakfast, and your coach will tell you by lunchtime whether it worked.

Start your resetHow it works

This article is general information, not medical advice. If you're worried about your blood sugar, talk to your GP.

Useful things, now and then.

A short email from the Nico team. No streaks, no guilt.

See it. Understand it.
Change it.

Start your reset300 places this month